Writing

Essays on evidence, minds and meaning. Each entry gives the argument in brief; open it for the full text.

Subject:

Showing 6 of 6 pieces

Academic writing

Full text: English · 514 words · Finished

Can the Pursuit of Power Constitute Self-Surpassing? A Nietzschean Reading of Il Dottore

Nietzsche's Zarathustra treats the will to truth as a form of will to power, and describes life as something that continually surpasses itself, even turning against its own creations. The essay asks whether Dottore's pursuit of knowledge changes who he is, or only makes him more ruthless in serving the same aim. It tests that question against three episodes: his erasure of his own Segments, his claimed calm towards setbacks, and his acceptance of the end of his final experiment. In each it finds a shift in priorities without clear proof that his understanding of himself has changed. The conclusion is that surpassing oneself need not mean abandoning an aim, but that it stays unresolved whether the aim has changed Dottore or has absorbed even the prospect of failure.

Read the piece →

Full text: English · 586 words · Finished

Gender Analysis using the Lens of the Middle Way

A search for a single necessary and sufficient criterion of gender assumes that gender has an intrinsic nature such a criterion could capture. Using the Madhyamaka arguments from emptiness and dependent origination, the essay argues that every candidate criterion (chromosomes, anatomy, hormones, social role, self-identification) depends on further conditions and concepts, so none can be an ultimate foundation. Because dependence and intrinsic essence exclude each other, gender has no essence. Gender categories nonetheless remain valid and useful as conventions in law, medicine and everyday life. The position is therefore neither essentialism nor nihilism: gender tracks real patterns, but is a conventional designation rather than an intrinsically existing thing.

Read the piece →

Full text: English · 2,363 words · Finished

Analysing Scientific Miracles in the Qur’an: A Barrier Between Two Seas

Fresh and salt water really can stratify, but a real phenomenon is not a prediction. This essay asks whether the “two seas” verses (Qur’an 55:19–20 and 25:53) are specific and non-obvious enough to count as scientific foreknowledge, and finds that the modern reading supplies most of the detail itself. It tests the claim against what ancient observers could see for themselves, against classical exegesis such as Ibn Kathir’s geographical reading of the separation, and against the meaning of barzakh, which is far broader than “halocline”. It concludes that the verses can reasonably be read as theological description of the natural world that is compatible with oceanography without predicting it.

Read the piece →

Full text: English · 539 words · Finished

Artificial Consciousness and the Nature of the Mind

If an artificial system could suffer, denying it moral consideration solely because it lacks a biological brain would be a moral failure, not merely a technical judgement. The essay asks whether that exclusion reflects a principled theory of mind or only the limits of current explanation. Surveying functionalism, biological naturalism and emergentism, it argues that none gives principled grounds for treating a biological substrate as metaphysically necessary rather than merely sufficient, given what we currently know. Because the uncertainty is real and the moral risk is asymmetric, it concludes that restraint is safer than dismissal, and that denying artificial consciousness reflects epistemic caution rather than philosophical necessity.

Read the piece →

Full text: Indonesian · 1,067 words · Finished

A Response to ‘The Secret of the Seven Heavens and the Universe of Angels’

This essay responds to a presentation that tries to reconcile Islamic cosmology with science, linking the seven heavens, the angels and the Isra’ Mi’raj to the Fermi paradox and the Kardashev scale. It argues that the case rests on a category error (applying a scale for physical civilisations to metaphysical beings), on equivocation over words such as energy and dimension, and on an argument from ignorance. It adds that the central claims are unfalsifiable and that the reading of the number seven is inconsistent. It closes by suggesting the presentation answers a sincere wish to hold faith and reason together, but does so at the cost of both.

Read the piece →

Full text: Indonesian · 710 words · Finished

The Politics of Scapegoating and the Accountability Crisis in Indonesia

Indonesia faces corruption, forest fires, air pollution and shrinking civil liberties, yet public debate keeps returning to the morality and existence of LGBTQ people. The essay reads this through scapegoating, comparing it with the anti-Chinese violence of May 1998, when official rhetoric and the redirection of public anger harmed a minority with little political protection. It points to Presidential Regulation 111 of 2025, which lists the spread of LGBTQ culture as a nonmilitary threat, and to the 2026 harassment of LGBTQ students and persecution of trans women in Bogor. It does not claim that every anti-LGBTQ campaign is a deliberate distraction, and it acknowledges that the 1998 comparison has limits. Its argument is that, whatever the intent, scapegoating works politically by directing anger at the powerless and narrowing scrutiny of those who hold power, and that ignorance does not remove responsibility for violence.

Read the piece →